I like the BSG feel of the exterrior shots... that really catches my eye. The bridge, though, just does NOT look Trek. Hell, even Galaxy Quest has a more militaristic feel to it, imo. I just don't know about this... I'm particularly not fond of the look of the antagonist. He just... looks really cartoony, you know? Like somebody you'd see off of Power Rangers.
Sure, the writers are well known, I won't argue that at all. But is it not important that the visuals [sets and actors, etc...] reflect Trek in the best manner possible? That's my only concern... that they went overboard. A more Enterprise/Galactica-style feel to the interriors would have been great, methinks. But who knows, maybe the story will be good enough to help me forget about the rest.