I both like and dislike Trekyards at times.
They say, they don't have a problem with a visiual reboot, but then again, they are nitpicking the hell out of it alot...
Sometimes they overdo it with geekiness, esepcially when they have the designers onboard (Sternbach, Drexler, etc.)
On the other hand, their Analysis are pretty good. I do really enjoy those two.
As for the "New" Enterprise:
I actually like it, exept those nacelle struts and, what appears to be, the window.