Many Years ago, a friend of mine on a forum for the game Battlestations Midway created a very popular thread called... Who would win? I created a similar topic with videos of those matches from a different ship game. It didn't go down well. However, although the original Who would Win thread has gone the way of the dinosaurs owing to a not very active community, I think it could be transferred to this place, which is still very much active.
The rules are simple: choose two starships of a similar class, display their specs (warp capability, amount of weapons etc.). Whereas the original thread discussed battleships and cruisers of WW2, this thread is comparing starships.
To make a bit simpler, these are the original specs needed, with their Star Trek equivilent:
Main Battery=primary energy weapons, like phasers
Secondary Battery=secondary energy weapons or number and type of torpedoes used
Armor=Does it have ablative armour, or is it only lightly armor
Speed=Obviously maximum warp speed
To try and make it even simpler to explain, heres the link to the original:
http://battlestations.eu/index.php/en/forum/topic?id=177If anyone likes the idea of this thread, just say so.