Finally saw it yesterday and I think its the best of the three. I had a feeling that we would get a ***** for this Batman series and I had a feeling that it was Blake the whole time. You just knew that there was going to be more to him than just being a cop.
I can't agree with you at all. I have a hard time putting ANY of the Dark Knight trilogy above the others, but if I had to pick just one, it would likely be Batman Begins. As much as I love The Dark Knight, it does have some reliance on the viewer having seen Batman Begins. The Dark Knight Rises is even worse, there are so many story threads that are tied back to Batman Begins that if you just go into Rises without seeing either of the first two you will be completely and totally lost.
And no, Blake is not that. At all. Ever. All that was was a pointless and idiotic name drop.
And I'll say this, I want the Batman series to be rebooted after this, but much later. I think it's time to drop the always dark, gritty stuff. You can have a dark movie without it being based entirely in realism and depression. Look at the Keaton film.
And that's not to say that the Nolan-verse shouldn't continue, but I think it should be left to another medium at this point since...certain things happen in the movie. It can continue in comics or an animated/cgi series, but I don't think it should continue on in film.