That FAQ looks at the movie in the worst possible way, ignoring explanations given within the film itself, and just builds up on its own egotistical pompousness to fuel itself.
I am so fucking sick and tired of people bashing on this movie for every single thing and they don't even have the balls to turn around and do the same for the rest of Trek. It has one of the most thought provoking plots out of the last half dozen films, and everyone just summarizes it into "two hours of brainless action". Its not the best Trek film, but it is well worth the 8s or 9s out of 10 it gets. You people ignore all the good points, find the trivial bad ones, and blow them up way out of proportion.
I'm tired of stupid idiot trekkies who claim they love Gene Roddenberry, then completely fly in the face of his philosophy of tolerance and bash everything new. Hypocrisy, all of it.