Am I the only one ignoring the pointless discussion and trying to be constructive?
Hehe. That's what I decided to do when I realized back on page 1 that there were two more pages to this thread.
JB06, when comparing your retexture to the original textures, I see exactly what you mean about the depth of the textures (nice job using shots to get your points across, by the way). I think you've done a wonderful job. These textures look absolutely superb. To me, the specular highlights coupled with the higher contrast in colors really make LC's textures--that is,
all the details--pop (which is really a compliment to LC's work, when you think about it).
LC made virtually all of the details
perfect in terms of location, and proportions (which, in my opinion, is the hardest part!). It looks to me like JB06 is just trying to make those details a pop a little more (and, thus, make them more true to the show, in his opinion).